Real Estate Buyer Commissions Tactics Putting You at Risk

The real estate market is constantly evolving, and recent changes have introduced new challenges and opportunities for both buyers and sellers.

One of the most significant shifts has been in how commissions are negotiated, a topic that has become even more relevant in light of the recent rule changes. Many real estate agents are finding themselves faced with the question: how do you navigate these new commission structures while still ensuring a fair deal for all parties involved?

Whether you’re a listing agent, buyer’s agent, or just trying to understand the dynamics at play, this post will give you the tools and insights to approach commission discussions with confidence. Let’s explore what’s working, what’s not, and how you can adapt to the evolving real estate landscape.

The Reality of a Competitive Market

In a market with numerous properties, it’s not uncommon for some sellers to face frustration when they don’t receive offers. However, it’s crucial not to give in to discouragement. Every listing has its challenges, and the key is to understand that persistence and adaptability are vital.

• High Inventory: With a plethora of properties available, buyers have more options to choose from.
• Buyer Perception: If a listing agent is seen as difficult to work with, it can deter potential buyers.
• Staying Positive: Despite tough times, it’s important for sellers not to get discouraged if they don’t receive offers immediately.

Steering and Ethical Considerations in Real Estate

For years, the term “steering” was a sensitive topic in real estate. Historically linked to issues involving protected classes, steering has been a subject that professionals were hesitant to address. However, the conversation has evolved, and it’s now a topic being discussed more frequently.

• Steering in the Industry: While it’s still associated with protected classes, steering now also includes discussions around how agents negotiate and present properties to clients.
• Adapting to Ethical Standards: It’s crucial for agents to remain aware of ethical guidelines while navigating complex negotiations.

Navigating Commission Negotiations

One of the most common topics discussed in today’s market is negotiating commissions, especially after recent changes that went into effect following the August 2023 settlement. These changes have had a noticeable impact on how commission structures are handled across the board.

The Commission Landscape Post-August Changes

A few months have passed since the changes to commission rules were implemented. Agents are now adjusting to these new guidelines and determining how they affect their negotiations.

• What’s Changed?: The market has not seen an overwhelming shift in how commissions are handled. Most agents have reported minimal changes, with some minor adjustments taking place.
• Survey Results: A poll conducted with agents showed that only 7% felt a significant change in commissions, while 55% noted little to no change. 28% observed some changes, indicating a gradual shift rather than a complete overhaul.

Understanding Commission Negotiation Trends

The new commission rules have also led to questions about how listing agents and buyer agents should approach commission negotiations. Some key questions include whether buyer agents are asking sellers to sign commission addendums or if buyer agents are negotiating the commission amount with sellers directly.

• Addendum Requests: A surprising 86% of agents reported that they have not been asked to sign an addendum agreeing to a commission amount before showing a property. This suggests that best practices are largely being followed.
• Negotiating Commission: Many buyer agents are still negotiating commission terms with sellers. This negotiation typically happens when the seller’s initial offering is lower than the buyer agent’s desired commission.

Understanding Buyer Broker Compensation Communication

Recent surveys show that 69% of listing agents proactively communicate buyer broker compensation contributions before or after property showings. For the remaining 31%, however, compensation details remain unclear until the offer stage. This statistic is intriguing, especially as markets vary. In competitive markets, transparent communication could streamline the negotiation process and reduce friction.

Negotiation in Action: A Case Study

Real estate negotiations are complex, and commission discussions often add an extra layer. In a real-world example, a buyer’s agent submitted an offer on a property with clear terms, including a request for a 3% broker contribution. However, the listing agent reminded the buyer’s agent that only a 2.5% contribution was offered. This single-term negotiation led to a lengthy discussion, with the listing agent taking issue with the buyer’s agent’s commission terms.

Crafting Responses to Protect Fiduciary Duty

In negotiations, focusing on a single contract term – such as broker compensation – can hinder progress. It’s essential to remember that all contract terms, including compensation, are negotiable. For example, some listing agents may emphasize the commission rate over other details, potentially affecting a buyer’s interest in the property.

Common Missteps and How to Avoid Them

As seen in real-world examples, some buyer agents insist on confirming compensation before even showing a property. This approach, while protective, may be seen as self-serving and may deter listing agents from engaging. To avoid creating friction, agents should consider the following tips:

Tips for Effective Communication

• Wait for Offer Stage to Confirm Compensation: Rather than confirming commission terms upfront, wait until your buyer expresses genuine interest in a property.
• Use Professional Language: Avoid bringing up internal commission splits or referral fees in client communications – it’s irrelevant to the negotiation.
• Treat Commission as Secondary: The buyer’s needs should guide all conversations; avoid making commission the focal point.

Preparing for Future Market Conditions

In a buyer’s market, agents may have more leverage in negotiating buyer broker compensation. However, as market conditions shift, especially if the market swings to favor sellers, buyer agents will need to refine their strategies to ensure fair compensation while providing value to their clients.

Preparation Tips:

• Stay Informed on Market Trends: Being aware of market trends can help you adjust your approach based on supply and demand.
• Focus on Value Proposition: Clearly communicate your services and value to clients, which will make commission discussions easier in any market.
• Practice Negotiation Scenarios: Run through different negotiation scenarios with peers to prepare for a range of client expectations.

Responding to Challenges Around Buyer Broker Compensation

Many agents may encounter challenges from listing agents who believe that commission negotiations compromise client interests. In cases like these, refocus on the overall client experience by using these response strategies:

Effective Response Tips:

• Share Client-Focused Examples: Substitute commission discussions with examples that better illustrate value, like repair requests.
• Use Client Education as a Tool: Brief clients on industry practices, like “steering,” to build trust and transparency in the process.
• Stay Professional in Emotionally Charged Situations: If a listing agent is highly protective over a specific commission percentage, keeping the conversation professional and client-focused can avoid tension.

---

Final Thoughts on Buyer Broker Compensation Negotiations

Commission discussions are just one component of a comprehensive real estate transaction. By focusing on the broader contract terms and treating compensation as one of many negotiable points, agents can better serve their clients, streamline negotiations, and minimize conflicts with colleagues.

To listen to more of our podcast episodes, visit The #RealtyHack Podcast Page. The #RealtyHack Podcast is also available to listen to on Spotify, Google Podcasts, Apple Music, and your other favorite podcast directories.

Sign up for my newsletter and get updated for the next #RealtyHack!